Reform of science assessment systems (CoARA)

Overview

The Coalition for Advancing Research Assessment (CoARA) is an international initiative that is committed to the fair, transparent and qualitative development of the assessment of scientific research. The German Psychological Society (DGPs) is actively involved in CoARA to promote sustainable changes in the assessment of psychological research. Our aim is to evaluate psychological science in such a way that not only bibliometric indicators (such as impact factor or number of publications) count, but that the quality, transparency and relevance of research also take centre stage. In this way, we support researchers in making scientifically innovative, replicable and socially relevant contributions.

Background & Goals

What is CoARA?

CoARA stands for the Coalition for Advancing Research Assessment, an initiative that was founded at European level in 2022 and now comprises more than 700 international research organisations. Its members include universities, learned societies and third-party funders such as the DFG and the ERC. The aim of CoARA is to critically scrutinise and sustainably improve existing evaluation practices. Instead of a purely quantitative evaluation of scientific achievements, CoARA favours qualitative, open and transparent criteria. The aim is to reduce problematic incentive systems that favour excessive publication pressure or an overvaluation of the impact factor, for example, and to improve the overall quality of research.

Goals of the DGPs within the framework of CoARA

  • Promote a quality-orientated research culture: We want scientific excellence, transparency and reproducibility to be rewarded more than pure quantity of scientific outputs. Scientific works should also be assessed individually and not heuristically on the basis of their publication organs.
  • Raising awareness: The DGPs provides assistance and guidance to support members in implementing new assessment standards in the field, e.g. in appointment committees, tenure track procedures or performance-based funding allocation...
  • Promote open science practices: We are committed to ensuring that open science practices, e.g. open data, transparent methods and comprehensible analyses, are systematically included in the evaluation of psychological research.
  • Valuing the diversity of scientific contributions: The diversity of scientific achievements, including contributions to teaching, transfer, data provision and infrastructure, should be recognised and integrated into the evaluation.

Activities of the DGPs

The DGPs pursues concrete measures to realise the goals of CoARA. Central to this is our Action Plan, which sets out concrete steps and initiatives.

  • Development of new assessment guidelines: Development of concrete recommendations and guidelines for fair and qualitative assessment practices. A particular focus here is the development and evaluation of new, valid approaches to the assessment of research performance as part of the RESQUE project. Specifically, one of the first steps will be to clarify the guidelines for awarding prizes within the DGPs.
  • Communication and sensitisation: Events to increase members' awareness and understanding of changes in accordance with the CoARA principles in research assessment.
  • Cooperation and exchange: Networking with international and national partner organisations to develop and implement common standards.

Materials & Resources

Here you will find key documents and recommendations from the DGPs relating to the implementation of the CoARA goals as well as further information and guidelines.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

What is CoARA and why is it relevant for psychologists?

CoARA stands for the Coalition for Advancing Research Assessment, an international association of institutions that advocates a reformed, fair and quality-orientated assessment of scientific achievements. For psychologists, this means moving away from a narrow focus on publication metrics and towards a more holistic view of scientific quality, openness, relevance and diversity of contributions.

What role does the DGPs play in CoARA?

The DGPs is the first German professional society to sign CoARA. It contributes psychology-specific perspectives to the debate and develops its own standards, materials and training programmes to support its members in implementing the CoARA principles.

Will this change the way research is evaluated?

In the long term, yes - and that is necessary. The evaluation of research should focus more on the quality of the work and its open, comprehensible nature. High scientific standards will be maintained, but the criteria will be more transparent, broader and more reflective.

What does this mean for us as researchers in concrete terms?

It could mean that the number of publications or the impact factor will no longer be the primary criteria for applications, funding applications or evaluations. Instead, contributions to open science, teaching, data provision or collaborative research will become more important. Work will be judged more on its quality and no longer primarily on where it was published. This also means that researchers will have more influence on the fulfilment of these criteria than is currently the case. The DGPs will provide guidelines and examples in this regard.

Do I have to actively adapt my research profile?

Not necessarily - but CoARA encourages a reflective presentation of your scientific work. It is worth thinking about new forms of scientific contributions and their documentation - for example through structured CVs, narrative presentations of achievements or emphasising open science practices.

Where can I find specific recommendations or templates?

In the Materials & Resources section, we provide key documents, guidelines and further links. These are regularly expanded and updated.

Contact us

If you have any questions about the work of the DGPs within the framework of CoARA or would like to become actively involved in the further development of research assessment, we look forward to hearing from you. The CoARA working group of the DGPs is available to you as a central point of contact.

Contact persons (Chair of the working group)