Since 2020, the German Psychological Society has had a central ombudsman committee. This deals with issues of good scientific practice, scientific misconduct and misconduct at work and study places at psychological institutes in Germany.
One of the tasks of the ombuds committee is to act as a point of contact for questions relating to suspected or observed scientific misconduct or misconduct in the workplace. The specific types of behaviour that may fall under these forms of misconduct can be found in these regulations. The Ombuds Committee can offer support in various forms, for example by providing an advisory assessment of the facts of the case and relevant points of contact, through to anonymised contact with relevant contact persons at the respective research institution.
The DGPs Ombudsperson Board is a complementary service to the DFG's contact points and those of local universities and research institutes. It sees itself as a low-threshold contact point that can be approached if those seeking advice do not (yet) wish to turn to an institutional ombudsman or ethics committee or if these do not provide support (but not if another committee has already finalised the case or is currently working on it). This offer is aimed at all prospective and trained psychologists and their employees at German higher education and research institutions, as well as all DGPs members in connection with the above-mentioned questions.
Initial contact with the ombuds committee is made by email to ombudsgremium(at)dgps.de or, if desired, directly with a member of the ombuds committee. Contact is usually answered within a maximum of 7 days.
Further information on the responsibilities of the ombuds committee and the procedure can be found in the regulations.
Members of the ombudsman panel
The ombudsman panel currently consists of five members. They are appointed by the Executive Board of the German Psychological Society for a period of four years. Contact can be made via the general e-mail address and - if desired - without disclosing your identity. Contact is treated confidentially and can only be viewed by the current members of the ombudsman committee. If desired, the individual members of the ombudsman's office can also be contacted directly via their work email addresses.
General: ombudsgremium@--no-spam--dgps.de
The current members of the committee are
- Prof Dr. Peter Kirsch (Chair), Central Institute of Mental Health Mannheim and Heidelberg University: peter.kirsch@--no-spam--zi-mannheim.de,www.zi-mannheim.de/forschung/personen/person/10013.html
- Prof Dr. Malte Elson, University of Bern: malte.elson@--no-spam--unibe.ch,www.dig.psy.unibe.ch/ueber_uns/personen/prof_dr_elson_malte/index_ger.html
- Prof Dr. Susann Fiedler, MPI for Research on Collective Goods: susann.fiedler@--no-spam--wu.ac.at,www.wu.ac.at/cobe/prof-dr-susann-fiedler/
- Prof Dr. Jutta Stahl, University of Cologne: jutta.stahl@--no-spam--uni-koeln.de,https://www.hf.uni-koeln.de/33398
- Le Vy Phan, University of Bielefeld: le.phan@--no-spam--uni-bielefeld.de
Data protection and data storage
The ombudsman board distinguishes between the storage of data generated for the processing of a current case and the long-term archiving of data from completed cases. In addition, the Ombudsman Board also keeps anonymous statistics on its activities.
Storage
In order to process cases effectively, it is necessary to store different types of data in different ways. Communication with the ombudsman board is initially by email. If the general email address ombudsgremium@dgps.de is used, the data is stored on the IONOS servers (more on data protection and technical security here (https://www.ionos.de/hilfe/datenschutz from IONOS). If contact is made via the official email address, the data protection regulations of the respective institution apply.
Handwritten notes made in the course of proceedings initially remain in the possession of the ombudsperson, who ensures their security. During long-term archiving, these notes are digitised (see below) and the originals are then destroyed. Digital documents and files that members of the ombudsman's office receive in the course of a case are stored on servers of the DRACOON storage service, where they are also archived long-term (see below). Local copies may be made if this is necessary to view the files.
Long-term archiving
In accordance with the recommendation of the Ombudsman for Science [https://ombudsman-fuer-die-wissenschaft.de/], all data relevant to the assessment and work of the ombudsman panel (documents, minutes of discussions and thoughts, letters, emails) are digitised and stored for a period of 15 years to protect all those involved. The Ombudsman Board uses the DRACOON storage service for this archiving (more on data protection and technical security [https://www.dracoon.com/de/datenschutz] of DRACOON here). All stored data is treated confidentially. Only the current members of the ombudsman board have access to the data at any time. Former members who have worked on a particular case can be consulted at a later date in the event of queries or uncertainties. At the end of the 15-year period, all stored data relating to a case is destroyed.
There are various reasons for this storage interest: It allows parties involved in proceedings to contact the ombudsman panel again with queries about the proceedings after they have been concluded, for example if a party involved does not honour agreements reached after proceedings. It also ensures the protection of individuals if a whistleblower repeatedly contacts the ombudsman board about the same issue because he/she did not agree with the assessment. The repeated spreading of false accusations by the same person can also only be detected if older data is still available and new members of the ombudsman board who were not involved in cases have access to this data. From the perspective of good scientific practice, the storage of case data from ombudsman work is necessary, not least with regard to institutional learning.
Reports and activities
In summer 2020, the Ombuds Panel conducted a survey to record as accurately as possible how many people have experienced or are experiencing academic misconduct and misconduct in the workplace in order to gain a representative impression of the state of academic psychology and systemic problems in academia in Germany.
The ombuds committee's report can be downloaded here (pdf file).
