Materials

Minimum Standards in Family Law Assessments

  • Following intensive collaboration between the various professional groups and specialist associations involved (psychologists, medical professionals and lawyers), a consensus paper on minimum standards in family law assessments was drawn up in 2015. In the view of the divisions, these minimum standards represent a significant step forward in improving and ensuring the quality of family law assessments. In particular, we consider it worth highlighting that professional qualification as a psychologist specialising in legal psychology is explicitly mentioned as fundamental proof of expertise and has thus been significantly strengthened.
  • An updated version of the MinimumStandards for Family Law Assessments (PDF) is now available in its second edition.

Scientific requirements for psychological assessments of testimony (credibility reports)

Whether a statement is based on a real-life experience can be assessed through a psychological assessment of testimony. It should be noted that credibility does not refer to the person as such (in which case one speaks of ‘credibility’), but solely to the statement made by that person. The minimum standards for expert assessments in such cases are based on the case law of the highest court (BGHSt 45, 164):Federal Court of Justice (BGH) judgement of 30 July 1999.

Minimum requirements for expert reports on criminal responsibility

In principle, the criminal liability for, and the sentencing in respect of, relevant criminal law behavior depend on whether the offender could reasonably have been expected to behave differently from how they did at the time of the offence. The minimum requirements set out in the following source are decisive for expert reports in this field: Boetticher, A., Nedopil, N., Bosinski, H. A. G., & Saß, H. (2007). Minimum requirements for reports on criminal responsibility. Forensic Psychiatry, Psychology, Criminology, 1(1), 3–9. Available online via Springer-Link: Forens Psychiatr Psychol Kriminol 1: 3–9 (2007). 

Minimum requirements for prognostic assessments

The first version of the ‘minimum standards’ for prognostic assessments was published as early as 2007: Boetticher, A., Kröber, H.-L., Müller-Isberner, R., Böhm, K. M., Müller-Metz, R., & Wolf, T. (2007). Minimum requirements for prognostic reports. Forensic Psychiatry, Psychology, Criminology, 1(2), 90–100. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11757-007-0017-9. Reprinted inForens Psychiatr Psychol Kriminol 1: 90–100 (2007). Following a three-year process, a new version was published in 2019, which focuses on the term ‘recommendations’. The source is: Boetticher, A., Koller, M., Böhm, K. M., Brettel, H., Dölling, D., Höffler, K., Müller-Metz, R., Pfister, W., Schneider, U., Schöch, H., & Wolf, T. (2019). Recommendations for prognostic reports: Legal framework for prognoses in criminal proceedings. Forensic Psychiatry, Psychology, Criminology, 13(4), 305–333. doi.org/10.1007/s11757-019-00557-0 and can be accessed via Springer-Link.